I can press a direction to the point the membrane gives way and the button is fully depressed, but no input is registered. This mostly happens with the down direction and it’s not every time.

I’m having this same exact issue. I thought it was just a defect on mine tbh.

I’m also slightly having issues with the D-Pad. I’m not sure if it’s a defect or not, but I have to put a little more force on down on the D-Pad in order for the input to register. Unlike my LCD SD, I can softly press down on the pad and it’ll register no problem.

512GB

Edit : So I spoke too soon and this just happened again when switching from desktop to gaming. I’m guessing I might need to RMA? :/