- cross-posted to:
- gadgets
- cross-posted to:
- gadgets
You must log in or register to comment.
3070(ti) 16Gb would make more sense. Same with 4070ies.
For gaming, that is of course.
Even with 12GB of VRAM would 3070/ti be so much better! And 3080 with 16-20GBs as well would be a much more viable card today.
Nvidia did sell these as quadros, and this was benchmarked by HUB. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=alguJBl-R3I
People also modded them with 16GB. Well, it’d be nice if there was a market for this, because people would still buy them.
3080 20 GB! W! W! W! W! W! W! W!
So based
Ok where do i buy them
That 16GB 580 sounds cool for memory-constrained scenarios, but it’d obviously make more sense to get a more powerful card entirely.
Would’ve been good budget option for hobby AI if it wasn’t about 200x slower than Intel A770 for SD/LLMs.
I agree. I did deep fakes years ago with my 580, and having 16GB of VRAM would’ve been great for dealing with larger models and whatnot, but it’s past its prime at this point. Most budget cards today would be faster than it in compute, so that would be the reasonable option compared to the novelty of a 16GB 580.
Also, is the A770 really 200x faster in SD/LLMs or is that an exaggeration? I’m asking out of curiosity. I did some SD with DirectML and it was certainly slow, around 2 minutes for a set of images.
Probably a bit of an exaggeration but not too much. Intel released OpenVINO, making the A770 about 7x faster than the RX 6700.
That sounds about right. Nvidia and Intel seem to have better computer API support than AMD, so it doesn’t surprise me that the A770 performs much better with OpenVINO compared to the 6700. Alchemist is generally powerful in computer anyways, so that helps too.
Yep, Dawid already made a video comparing an original RX580 8gb vs the circumcised RX580 with 16gb. Out of all the games he tested there’s only 1 that utilizes that 16gb memory but it’s below 10fps! lmao.
Maybe it makes some sense in the AI arena. But I tend to agree that going with a better GPU is the way to go.
As for using RTX 3080,… for AI. I think Chinese have issues with sanctions.
Heh, caught me off guard with that description.
That video sounds about right. The place that more VRAM would be useful in is with compute, such as machine learning and video and photo editing, CAD, etc. I was doing image upscaling for the frames of a video a while ago, and it’s easy to fill up all 8GB of VRAM by upscaling enough images at once.
But the 580 is old by now, so it wouldn’t make sense to get a 16GB one for that either.
It wouldnt make much sense at all but Id like to have one. Really wouldnt mind seeing a Vega VII modded like this with more ram or even a vega 56 or 64. Those can be setup to sip the power and remain very capable for compute.
Im actually loving what the crypto crash has been doing. So many cool options for a decent price. At least where I live.
That’s fair. I’d love to have one for a collection as well. Crypto has indeed churned out some cool mods of pre-existing cards. The machine learning boom might also incentivize more mods of this nature, since that benefits from VRAM just as crypto did.
Vega uses HBM memory that is on the package, unlike GDDR which just sits on the PCB. That mod would be much more complicated if not outright impossible.
Ah didnt think of that was just thinking about how the frontier edition is the same exact thing just with more ram and modified firmware and how there were even larger stacks of hbm2 memory available so the possibility of a vega 64 with even more ram seemed exciting. Properly tuned with amdmemorytweak or even just a good undervolt and they can be very efficient.
Even the 5500xt 8gb could provide some decent compute power with a bit of tuning or going in with more power tool and really unlocking the memory.
Would be awesome to have total control over your cards like that. Like oh I want this gpu but with this much ram at this speed using only this much power and easily making that a reality.
Idk im really into this stuff and have several of the chinese motherboards with old chipsets and modded bioses on them too. Kinda cool having a cheap unlocked xeon system that for the most part is totally usable. Before that years back was modding asus made hp motherboards to overclock xeons and running mobile amd chips in dual cpu systems to oc.
Could keep a lot of stuff out of the dumps and in use this way which I think is a good thing. Hopefully they figure this out on better cards the 580 is pretty weak
All Vega support HBCC. You can just turn HBCC on and tell games you have more VRAM, which does provide a performance boost in games that actually need it. If you don’t need it, it does nothing.
I remember that made some benchmarks really happy. Havent tried it in years seemed pretty hit or miss, wonder if theres any reason to try it out again. Seemed to benefit the lows more than anything.
Idk Ill probably keep using these cards for quite a while. The VII is a beast for compute 64 and 56 both good too and still able to game with them at more than acceptable frame rates and resolutions. Idk I guess what I considered acceptable might not be the norm though I was watching videos about various handhelds for my son who wants to buy one and the people in them were calling 52 fps unplayable.
I mean for a local llama setup or stable diffusion the 580 could be nice.
But would have to use OpenVINO with an OpenCL backend instead of using ROCM as I think these have been removed from ROCM.
… unless there is a good Vulkan backend these days.
Dawid has great videos. I love that type of content where tech people test random “weird” hardware.
My previous GPU was a 4GB RX580 and it definitely was VRAM limited. 8GB is probably the sweet spot for that card (I might’ve kept mine longer if it had 8GB), but, at least for gaming, I don’t really see a point in having 16GB on a card with that level of performance
The power draw was already a lot with a 3080 12gb. I traded in for a 4070ti (on sale for $800 at the time for a higher end AIB) and cut my overall PC power consumption by 30%-50%! Since I pay the electric bill, this feels good. And I’m getting more frames. The 12g has been more than adequate so far and handles 4k well enough in any application so far. ☺️
Makes sense. The energy usage probably wouldn’t be noticeable over the course of a year for normal usage, but that’s still a decent trade. A more efficient card that’s also faster. Pretty good.
Yeah you really need like at least 3070 performance levels to properly use more than 8gb Vram without crippled performance. And that’s already more than 100% faster in most modern games. So yeah while the 580 was a very decent card for its time it obviously aged and now is only low end with horrible efficiency compared to anything modern.
Agreed.
16gb… 580s? Those aren’t even getting driver updates anymore, right?
thats actually kinda cool
I have both a 3060ti (in use) and a RX580 (in storage, needs new fans). I would like to add 8gb ram to both to extend the use of them and just learn something new.
Should probably practice with the 580 first though. Would probably use it for passthrough or something.
Its not so simple as just soldering in new ram. Requires a bios flash (polaris pro) as well.
a RX580
An*
R is a vowel noise, ar ex five eighty
Unless they pronounce RX as rix, which I have unfortunately seen before.
Nvidia and AMD should have allow AIB freedom to put whatever amount of Vram they like.
It use to be like this. We had 4GB GTX960, R9-285, gtx680/770, 8GB 290X.
Laptop use to have double of vram back in old days. Nowadays they have less than Desktop ones… zzz
I refuse to buy a 4060/4070 laptop because of 8GB vram, Laptop screen has since moved to 2560x1600p. There is no way 8GB is enough for a 1600p screen.
Well if you are thinking about playing the newest AAA games with 8GB of VRAM in high settings it won’t be enough, but it really depends on the game. My laptop has a 3070 and I can run games like Doom eternal at 2160p high 60 FPS but Modern warfare 3 for example if it’s not with DLSS and 1600p low then I can forget about anything above 60 FPS.
I could be wrong but wouldn’t there be a pretty high demand in China considering the need for large vram for Ai stuff. I don’t pretend to know much of anything about it, but wasn’t that the reason the 4090 was banned for sale in China?
no not really. they still need beefier compute units too and most of the banned cards were ai purposed stuff that you cant game on… with upton128gb VRAM… so the 580 16gb is probably not super useful.
werd, so i was wrong lol. thanks
RX580 just refuses to die
They have been doing those 580 with 16GB for awhile now. Saw some youtube videos were it show it ran slower vram and thus did not make much difference for gaming. But if someone has some app that needs vram for other uses it may be worth it. I think the 3080 has better chance of taking advantage of more vram. Will be interesting to see how much this modified gpus will cost.
The RTX 3080 definitely could take advantage of extra VRAM, with just 10 GB it can struggle in some tittles on Ultra settings at 4K.
With just 10GB it can struggle in some titles on Ultra settings at
4K1440p.With just 10GB it can struggle in some titles on Ultra settings at
4K1440p1080p (Hogwards Legacy, RE4…).
16gb on a rx 580 is a useful as men having nipples.
It leaves an option open and enhances certain experiences when given proper attention?
Sorry what was the point you were trying to make?
Sooo, not necessarily practical, but a lot of fun.
Do they even come with warranty? lol, I’d imagine these have been beat to hell already and will probably fail in less than a year.
I believe 3XXX series of Nvidia would have been stellar, if 3060ti and 3070/ti had at least 12GB and 3080/ti 16GB of VRAM. Owners of these would have almost zero incentives to upgrade them which is why Ngreedia gimped these GPUs on VRAM. Both sad and horrible decision.
Would be nice to see benchmarks of those 3080s with 20GB of vram.
That’s pretty sick. Can the 580 do anything with most AI though? The ones I see are using CUDA.
